Stockton University Partners with ACUE to Drive Student Success Read More

Deliberative Dialogue: A Catalyst for Critical Thinking

September 10, 2025
ACUE Editorial
Faculty member engaged in deliberative dialog with students

We are living in a time when meaningful conversation feels increasingly out of reach. As respectful public discourse continues to erode, many shy away from difficult conversations altogether, uncertain of how to engage without conflict. Yet progress and learning depend on our ability to hear new perspectives and broaden our understanding of the world. 

Without structured opportunities for discussion, classrooms risk becoming echo chambers—which does not align with higher education’s responsibility to open minds and prepare students for engaged citizenship. Deliberative dialogue offers a way forward, providing faculty with a proven framework to foster constructive conversations, encourage critical thinking, and equip students with the collaboration and problem-solving skills they need in college, careers, and civic life.

“In deliberative dialogue, I see my students become more curious and engaged. They learn to respect each other’s voices and to take responsibility for their own views – and their own learning.” 

— Peter Felten, PhD, Professor of History, Executive Director of the Center for Engaged Learning, and Assistant Provost for Teaching and Learning, Elon University

A Path to Thoughtful Communication

ACUE has launched a five-part series on deliberative dialogue, offering short, flexible Quick Studies that provide faculty with practical strategies for embedding this approach across disciplines and course formats. Whether new to deliberative dialogue or seeking to refine existing practice, instructors gain ready-to-use tools to prepare students for meaningful conversations that advance learning and civic readiness.

  1. What Is Deliberative Dialogue? Explore how deliberative dialogue differs from traditional college classroom discussion and debate, and how it helps build students’ civic awareness of complex issues, critical thinking, and communication skills.
  2. Integrating Deliberative Dialogue into Your Course Incorporate deliberative dialogue into your course in a purposeful way by selecting timely topics, essential resources, and planning assessments to evaluate the learning.
  3. Preparing for Deliberative Dialogue Through Practice Equip students for deliberative dialogue by setting community norms, teaching active listening, and creating low-stakes practice opportunities to build student confidence and communication skills.
  4. Launching a Deliberative Dialogue Apply a structured framework to present relevant issues, revisit community norms, and outline multiple stances on complex issues to jumpstart productive classroom dialogue.
  5. Facilitating a Deliberative Dialogue Guide students through deliberative dialogue by facilitating structured discussions, addressing common challenges, and using debriefing strategies.

A Clear Starting Point for Faculty

This series gives faculty a clear starting point and practical support for bringing deliberative dialogue to life in their classrooms. Participants gain ready-to-use strategies to foster respectful and evidence-based discussions, guidance on choosing meaningful topics, and techniques to keep conversations on track—even when disagreements arise. The Quick Studies also include real classroom examples from experienced educators, showing how dialogue can be launched, sustained, and debriefed in ways that build student confidence and strengthen learning.

Strengthening Institutions Through Dialogue

The benefits of deliberative dialogue extend beyond individual classrooms. Institutions that support this work create learning environments where students feel safe engaging with challenging topics and considering diverse perspectives. They build cultures of respect and inquiry, preparing graduates who are not only career-ready but also civic-minded—graduates who are collaborative leaders capable of bridging divides and rebuilding trust in their communities.

Transforming the Way Students Engage

All five Quick Studies on deliberative dialogue were launched in early September 2025. Designed to be flexible, focused, and impactful, they provide faculty with everything needed to bring meaningful conversations into their teaching. Learn more about ACUE’s Quick Study series and discover how deliberative dialogue can transform the way your students engage, learn, and lead. Enroll in ACUE Commons for access to all Quick Studies.

The ability to engage in civil, informed, and productive dialogue has become a defining skill for both civic life and professional success. By equipping faculty with strategies to guide these conversations, institutions affirm their commitment to preparing students with the skills to engage constructively in the world they will shape.

ACUE Editorial
With contributions from researchers, thought leaders, and subject matter experts, our editorial team is dedicated to providing relevant and thoughtful insights on effective teaching practices and student success.

More from ACUE

ACUE Constructive Conversations between faculty and students

Constructive Conversations: 5 Guidelines for Fostering Them in Your Course

I am sitting in a large meeting space at a university in Texas with tables spread across the room. Each ...

Read more
Faculty engaged in discussion in front of informational board at event

Get Connected: 5 Reasons to Support Your Faculty With Community

Faculty members serve as the pillars supporting higher ed institutions. Their contributions extend far beyond the classroom—shaping minds, fostering critical ...

Read more
Female instructor in front of students with computer monitors

Unlocking Human-AI Potential​: 10 Best Practices for AI Assignments in Higher Ed

In the early days of December 2022, late one night, under the cover of darkness, I eagerly typed “ChatGPT” into ...

Read more
NHETC graduates with caps on

Improving the Quality of Teaching and Learning: Why Community Colleges Invest in Faculty Professional Development with ACUE

Community colleges remain a critical component of the higher education system—providing pathways to education and the workforce for millions of ...

Read more
Image of circles connected by lines

Preparing for the Future: The Impact of AI on Higher Education

Since the emergence of generative artificial intelligence (AI)—most notably ChatGPT—the general discourse in higher education has been a tale of ...

Read more

4 Ways Faculty Can Be Allies for College Student Mental Health

Mental health disorders are common, consequential, and largely untreated on college campuses. These findings are evident through data from the Healthy ...

Read more

Beyond the Icebreaker: Building Community in the Classroom

I’ve been fortunate to have that seemingly ‘magical’ class. You know the one—small, seminar-style setup with students actively engaged in ...

Read more
Instructor with smiling students on laptops

Navigating the Need for Rigor and Engagement: How to Make Fruitful Class Discussions Happen

Derek Bok’s great book Our Underachieving Colleges contains a passage that, ultimately, transformed my teaching. Teaching by discussion can also seem forbidding ...

Read more

Why We’re “Speaking Up” About Inclusive Teaching Strategies

Kelly Hogan and Viji Sathy on “speaking up” about inclusive teaching strategies.

Read more

Let’s Connect!